Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

NFL

2025 Super Bowl MVP voting: Cooper DeJean won fans’ vote, should an Eagles defender have won MVP?

The selection of Jalen Hurts as Super Bowl LIX MVP was hardly a surprise in the wake of the Eagles 40-22 bludgeoning of the Chiefs on Sunday night. We’ve seen time and time again the quarterback pull in the hardware in these situations and not just because of the importance of the position. 

As noted here plenty of times, the voting process is somewhat flawed, because it essentially asks for several volunteers from the media who are writing on deadline to quickly submit a vote for the Most Valuable Player in a game that’s currently ongoing or close to ending. 

For games with a wild ending, it’s a really difficult task. And it’s why you often see defensive players win MVP in games that turn into one-sided affairs. Which is why it was a little surprising we didn’t get a defensive player winning the award after the Eagles completely shut down the Chiefs offense outside of garbage time, much of which featured the Eagles backups against the Chiefs starters. 

Hurts was certainly a perfectly fine candidate, no question about it. He completed 17 of 22 passes for 221 yards and a pair of touchdowns, while running for another score. The other top MVP candidate, Saquon Barkley, was held in check by the Chiefs defense, and Hurts responded by stepping up in the passing game. 

But as good as Hurts was in the game, you could easily argue the defense was more important to the Eagles success and one of the many defenders who stepped up could have received the votes.

And the public agrees. According to Mike Florio of ProFootballTalk.com, rookie cornerback Cooper DeJean actually received the most votes of any player on a public NFL.com poll during the game, which is worth 2.5 votes out of a possible 20 total votes. 

Hurts finished second, receiving one vote, and defensive end Josh Sweat got a half vote for finishing third.

The remaining 16 votes are largely unaccounted for, although PFT’s Charean Williams had one of the votes as a Pro Football Writers’ Association voter, and revealed she put Sweat — who helped force Patrick Mahomes second interception when he bull-rushed Joe Thuney into the Chiefs quarterback — down on her ballot. 

It’s picking nits to a degree to complain about Hurts winning the award for sure. But there’s been cases to be made before that someone other than the quarterback deserved the MVP, even in an instance like Tom Brady leading the Patriots back from down 28-3, when there was a very viable case to be made for James White, who scored a total of three touchdowns including the game-winning one, as the man who got the free Disney World trip. 

In this particular case, Hurts had extremely similar stats to Russell Wilson in Super Bowl XLVIII, when the Seahawks young quarterback completed a high percentage of passes on a low number of attempts with a pair of touchdowns and a blowout occurred because of an outrageous performance by an elite defense that managed to find the end zone and setup several scores. 

DeJean scored as many times as Hurts and probably had a bigger impact because of his interception. Sweat finished the game with 2.5 sacks, three quarterback hits and six total tackles as well as the pressure that led to the interception that setup the Eagles to make it 24-0 at half (instead of Mahomes potentially driving for points and getting the ball back after half). 

Winning a Super Bowl MVP is a rare thing and it’s a rarer thing for a defender to put on their resume. You can easily make the case one of the Eagles defenders should have ended up winning the award but for a pretty flawed voting process. 



Read the full article here

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

MLB

Free-agent infielder Yoán Moncada has agreed to a one-year contract worth $5 million with the Los Angeles Angels, reports the New York Post. The...

MLB

Major League Baseball is now just days away from seeing camps open across Florida and Arizona in preparation for the exhibition season. There are...

NBA

The 2025 NBA trade deadline is here, and there’s been no shortage of action. Below is each trade and how the moves will impact...

NFL

We’ve reached the end of the road, and it’s brought us to Super Bowl LIX. Under the lights of the Superdome, the Philadelphia Eagles...